Inside the latest VG
Published monthly since 1986
129

Gibson 1958-’60 Les Paul Standard

A 'Burst by Any Other Name...
 
A 'Burst by Any Other Name...

One Thousand, Seven Hundred and Twelve.

To the uninformed, 1,712 is simply a number. But in guitardom, it’s arguably the number. After all, 1,712 is the number of Les Paul Standards Gibson produced between 1958 and 1960. And little did the company know that by simply giving the maple tops of its longstanding Les Paul model a sunburst finish, it would create a phenomenon, even if it didn’t immediately create a viable market.

But it did. Because even though it took years to happen, the ’58 to ’60 Les Paul Standard was the first solidbody electric guitar to become truly, and unquestionably, collectible.

The Les Paul model debuted in 1952 with P-90 pickups, a trapeze tailpiece, and gold-painted top after jazz guitarist Les Paul approached the Michigan-based Gibson Electric Instruments a second time in hopes of coercing company president Maurice Berlin into making an electric guitar that wouldn’t feed back when amplified at higher volumes, like archtop/hollowbody electrics of the day were prone to do. Though rebutted when he first presented the idea in the late 1940s, he was more convincing upon his return in part because the upstart Fender Musical Instruments had been very successfully marketing a solidbody electric since 1950.

From ’52 to ’58, the Les Paul Model evolved to include humbuckers, a stud tailpiece, the Tune-O-Matic bridge, and – in late ’53/’54 – a black finish on the new Custom variation.

Despite Gibson’s attempts to develop mass-market appeal for the Les Paul, the increasing popularity of the newfangled “Rock and Roll” music (with its propensity for twangy tones) meant that within a few years, interest in the model began to fade, in part because Les Paul’s own popularity had peaked, but also because the guitars that bore his name had gained a reputation for being heavy.

By ’58, Gibson, looking to increase the model’s share of the market, needed an alternative to its black and gold finishes. So it was that on or about June 30, 1958, the “sunburst” finish – perhaps the oldest use of paint and lacquer on electric guitars – met the Les Paul. Thus, the ‘Burst was born.

Musical Magic
Any guitar player will be quick to say that finish alone does not a fine guitar make. From the start, Les Pauls were made primarily of mahogany. As Les Paul himself tells it, much work went into deciding which woods to use.

“The first thing we considered was sustain,” he said. “The purpose of the model was to sustain without having to mother a note or pick the string twice. And it needed to be even, long, and with distinctive decay.”

The model’s “perfection” was aided along the way by several key developments, most importantly the humbucking pickup and the Tune-O-Matic bridge. So when the Standard was being prepped for market, things came together perfectly.

“It had the right combination of mahogany and maple – and pickups,” Paul said.

But goldtops and Black Beauties offered heaps of sustain, in part because both had been given the gift of humbuckers. Still, the market wasn’t reacting like Gibson had hoped. The guitar needed something more.

Flame, Curl, Quilt, Tiger-Stripe, etc…
When Gibson opted to fancy-up the 1/4″ maple cap on its Les Paul by adding a sunburst finish, its plan was to make the guitar more accepted in the marketplace.

And from all indications, those caps were applied randomly, with no regard for degree of flame. So throughout the original Standard’s production life, that flame ranged from nearly nonexistent to outright exquisite.

In the eyes of players of the day, those with flamed tops had an air of upper-crust quality and craftsmanship.

“The curl connects the ‘Burst to the world of fine violins,” said noted author and former Gibson historian Walter Carter. “And it gives each guitar its own identity. So you never get tired of looking at them.”

“The [looks] set it apart from just being functional,” added longtime ‘Burst aficionado Tom Wittrock, Third Eye Music. “While most guitars with curly maple used it on the back, this one brought it to the front for all to enjoy.”

“Each one, because of the differences in the wood tops, has a unique personality,” says veteran So Cal-based collector/dealer Norman Harris.

The PAF
The most vital part of the ‘Burst’s tone is its pickups. In ’57, the Les Paul Model and ES-175 semi-hollowbody were used as platforms to launch a new type of pickup called the “humbucker.”

Designed by Gibson electronics whizzes Seth Lover and Walter Fuller, the humbucker’s purpose was to eliminate the buzz and hum associated with playing in live settings where a guitar player could encounter interference from a host of sources. It started life as part number p.u. 490 in Gibson books at the time, but is commonly called a “Patent Applied For” or “PAF,” in reference to the small sticker on its bottomplate, placed there to discourage other companies from copying the design.

Though work on the hum-cancelling design began in 1955, Lover wasn’t officially granted the patent (#2896491) until July, 1959. But in an apparent effort to further intimidate potential copycats, Gibson used the “Patent Applied For” sticker until late ’62, when a new decal was employed showing the patent number.

Those who’ve heard many PAFs know there can be a significant difference in tone and output from one to the next. The reason is simple.

“Gibson’s winding machines of the day did not have automatic-stop counters, and they turned about 2,060 turns per minute,” said pickup manufactuer Seymour Duncan, who has done extensive reverse-engineering of PAFs. “So although the design called for each of two coils to be wound with 5,000 turns of 42 plain enamel copper wire, many were made with significantly more turns simply because the person working the winders couldn’t watch each machine closely enough to stop it at precisely 5,000.”

So over-winds of 15 to 20 percent weren’t unusual, and as a result, there are PAFs with 5,500 to 6,000 turns (or more) of wire!

The magnets in ‘Burst PAFs were made of Alnico II and IV (the numeric designation indicating the “grade” or formulaic mix of aluminum, nickel, and cobalt – the higher the number, the stronger the magnetic field it produces), which are also made to tolerances, but still vary from one to the next.

The Complete Package
After all was said and done, what the world had was simply the ultimate solidbody electric guitar. In the words of noted Nashville collector/dealer George Gruhn, “The sunburst Les Paul is the Gibson solidbody guitar in which everything ‘comes together’; they look great, they feel great, and they sound great. They have all the best features Gibson ever offered on a solidbody guitar.”

Plus, “Playability and rarity,” added Vic DaPra, proprietor of Guitar Gallery, and author of the book Sunburst Alley: A Pictorial Gallery of the Sunburst Les Paul 1958-1960. “And I think the woods they chose were much better back then. They were dried better, they were older.”

“The feel of a ’58 and ’59 necks, the sound of two PAFs, and the way the maple top reacted with the mahogany body, not to mention the sunburst finish and the flame…” said Drew Berlin, vintage specialist for Guitar Center/Hollywood Vintage. “They all combine to make hard, sweet magic.”

But as eyecatching as the sunburst finish was, especially when it was on a beautiful flamed top, and as smoothly as the guitar played, and as sweet as the PAFs sounded, ultimately, Gibson couldn’t justify keeping the guitar on the market…

Gaining Notoriety
Though market factors forced Gibson to eliminate the single-cutaway Les Paul in the latter half of 1960, the design ultimately proved to be far ahead of its time; and its untimely demise ultimately proved the reason we covet the ‘Burst today.

The Les Paul name remained attached to Gibson’s new double-cutaway thin-bodied SG until late 1963, several months, apparently, after the second of two five-year licensing agreements expired between Gibson and Les Paul. The SG held its own in the market through most of the ’60s as it underwent variations in pickups, tailpieces, finishes, and appointments.

But while Elvis ruled the pop music scene in the late ’50s (with the help of Scotty Moore and his Super 400), and the Beatles “arrived” carrying Rickenbackers and writing pop for the masses, there were percolations about… Almost simultaneously, two players – one in the U.S., one in England – started making waves with both their playing styles and their instruments.

In the U.K. in early ’65, axeman Eric Clapton had parted ways with the Yardbirds because he wanted to play pure blues. He hooked up with John Mayall and became the first in a revolving-door lineup of superstar guitarists in Mayall’s Bluesbreakers. But he was in the band long enough to plug a ’59 ‘Burst into a Marshall 1962 combo and make history by recording one of the all-time most influential albums in blues/rock history – John Mayall’s Blues Breakers featuring Eric Clapton. Friends call it “Beano.”

Back in the U.S., a kid in Chicago had also started drawing notice for playing hardcore blues. Michael Bloomfield spent a good part of his youth sneaking into Windy City blues clubs – often as the only white person in the house – and though he never recorded an album as influential as the Mayall/Clapton set, his playing exposed the white masses to the wonders of the blues. And guitar players were all over it – they had to have what he was playing. And in his heyday, Bloomfield was playing a ‘Burst.

“In my opinion, Bloomfield was the single most important, most significant player who ever played a sunburst Les Paul,” said Gruhn, who was selling guitars when Bloomfield emerged. “He, more than anyone, is the one who revived interest in the model. And though he never was a great commercial success, he was a cult figure greatly revered by other players. Some have success selling albums and making money, but have little or no impact on guitar trends. Bloomfield created the demand for Les Paul models, and for vintage electric guitars, in general.”

So it was that ‘Burst mania came to be, though its beginnings were humble.

By the late ’60s, however, burgeoning guitar giants like Jimmy Page, Jeff Beck, Peter Green, and Mick Taylor were all playing them in the studio and live. Gibson saw the writing on the wall, and in 1968, it revived the single-cutaway Les Paul model. Then, as Led Zeppelin rose to heights unseen for a hard rock/blues-based band, Page became the de facto ‘Burst El Capitan.

“Page, without a doubt, is the number one reason anyone is paying the big bucks today,” said Timm Kummer, vintage buyer for Mars Music. “I remember other guys playing ‘Bursts before him, but he put the thing on the minds of all the earliest guys I sold them to.”

As the ’70s kept on truckin’, other players joined Page in keeping the ‘Burst mystique alive, by using it to make some of the greatest rock and blues music ever put to record.

“Duane Allman hits home for me,” said Berlin. “Also, Billy Gibbons and his famous ‘Burst, ‘Pearly Gates,’ could do no wrong in my book.”

The Ultimate Collectible Guitar?
Again, the ‘Burst is arguably the reason solidbody electric guitars are collectible today. But even in the late ’60s and very early ’70s, you needed serious money to get one: $600 to $800. That was “holy grail” coin at the time, and also could’ve gotten you into a Martin Herringbone.

But then came Page, Beck, and company, and by the mid ’70s demand had increased to the point a would-be owner needed $2,000 to $3,000 to play ball. By the early ’80s, prices were creeping (or had crept) to $5,000.

Then, when the babyboom generation emerged and started buying and collecting guitars, things got really crazy.

“From 1984 through the end of ’92, most collectible guitars, banjos, and mandolins increased in price tenfold,” said Gruhn. “The sunburst Les Paul was no exception.”

Wanna Play?
If you’re looking to get into the ‘Burst club today, bring your checkbook – after you sell the lodge at Aspen and call your broker – and prepare to heed the advice of many dealers who warn against being hypnotized by an exotic 3-D quilty/flamey/curly top.

“Newer collectors are putting too much finality into a guitar with a cracked headstock or a removed Bigsby, or one that’s been refretted,” said DaPra. “If the guitar hasn’t been totally boogered or refinished or had new pickups, then there has to be a market for them. They’re still very valid, and the anality of many a new collector is keeping them from getting their first ‘Burst.

“There are a lot of fine examples out there, whether they be with a cracked headstock, or removed Bigsby. And they don’t stay on the market very long, so to knock their value down 30 or 50 percent is insane. When you’re searching for a ‘Burst, but you keep passing them up, you’re going to end up with nothing.”

“For myself and many of my ‘Burst buddies, the wood grain is the motivating factor in how much desire we personally have for a particular ‘Burst,” said Wittrock. “And yes, I would rather have ‘wood’ (curly maple) than pristine condition, assuming a guitar is usable. But it’s a shame some collectors can’t see past the dollar value. Being obsessed with perfection has led to many great ‘Bursts being looked down upon simply because they were repaired, made in 1960, or had a Bigsby tailpiece.

“Some of the best ‘Bursts I’ve ever owned were not in pristine condition. And I’ve never experienced a ‘bad’ ‘Burst, except when one suffered some calamity.

“They all sound a little different, play a little different, and weigh a little different, but they all seem great to me.”

“I think many collectors and players are entirely too wrapped up in worrying about the grain of the wood rather than the quality of the instrument,” added Gruhn. “I have difficulty understanding why someone would pay multiples more for a sunburst Les Paul with beautifully figured curly maple. While the curly example is certainly worth a lot of money, and should carry some premium, I don’t see why that premium should be $50,000 or more when a plain-grained example will play and sound exactly the same.

“One can buy the real thing with plain grain and still have enough money left over to panel one’s entire house in exquisitely curly maple, and even finish it in sunburst if you desire!”

Crystal Ball
So what does the future hold? While trying to predict such things is akin to guessing when aliens will visit Earth, few dealers see any reason to believe the market will do anything but continue to go up.

“The ‘Burst market is stronger than ever,” said Richard Friedman, vintage product manager for Sam Ash Music. “The most recent sales I know of include $200,000 for one that was one serial number away from the Frehley ‘Burst, $175,000 for a mint flametop, and the Bloomfield guitar, I’m told, sold for approximately $250,000. I think ‘Bursts will eventually bring $300,000 to $500,000.”

“I see no end in sight to the interest in ‘Bursts and their escalating prices,” added Wittrock. “Twenty years ago, when they reached $5,000, many people said that was the limit. I said then that we weren’t even close. And I still think we aren’t.

“About 10 years ago I said they could reach $1,000,000 some day, and I don’t see a reason to back off of that. We’re still a long way from it, but the market has shown plenty of strength lately, and prices have surpassed $100,000 on a few magnificent examples.”

“The ‘Burst is long-established as a classic design, and consequently the only threat to the market might be a technological advance that would make the electric guitar as we know it obsolete,” suggested Carter. “The demand for plainer examples and less-than-pristine ‘players’ might be affected in that situation, but the ‘Burst has such strong aesthetic and historical appeal that it’s hard to imagine the market ever going soft for nice examples.”

DaPra agrees wholeheartedly.

“I think the market hasn’t even hit its peak yet,” he said. “It’s just going to keep getting crazier and crazier.

“The ‘Burst is the Stradivarius of the 20th century; it’s just the best electric guitar ever made.”

VG would like to thank everyone who helped create this piece. If you’re travel plans include New York City anytime soon, go see Les Paul play at the Iridium. He’s there on Monday nights, and quite often has some special guests stop by to sit in.


My First ‘Burst
Longtime Players Recall Their First Loves

Vic DaPra
“In ’72, a girl bought me my first one, from Guitar Trader. She said, ‘I know you’ve got to have this guitar, so I’m going to buy it for you!’ I said, ‘Yeah, right.’ But a friend of mine went with her, and they surprised me with it!

“But my first purchase was in Wheeling, West Virginia, for $1,600. In ’73, that was an absurd amount of money – just insane! And it was dinged up and had some nicks. People thought I was crazy, and I was scared to death for borrowing that much. But it was a ’59 – serial number 9 1891.”

Tom Wittrock
“My first encounter with a ‘Burst, face to face, was a chance meeting with Billy Gibbons in 1972 or ’73.

“I was tagging along with my older brother, Bart, and our friend, Everett. Everett grew up in Billy’s neighborhood. While we were visiting Everett one day, we drove through town and ended up stopped at a intersection – and there was Billy, coming the other way.

“Everett hollered at him, and we went to Billy’s house to look at guitars.

“I pretty well kept my mouth shut while Billy showed us some cool stuff. He said “Pearly” was somewhere else – the rehearsal place, maybe? But he did have a totally faded ‘Burst he called the ‘Unburst.’ It was the first time I had heard about the color fading. I was lucky enough to touch it, but of course, I didn’t really get to play it.

“I was a big fan of Billy’s and I knew that ‘Bursts were cool. I also knew that ‘Pearly’ was something special. And seeing my first ‘Burst at Billy Gibbons’ house was a very special moment, for sure!

“I bought my first ‘Burst in the fall of ’75, after I’d moved to Springfield, Missouri. A friend saw an old Les Paul in a red sunburst finish at a local music store. I sped over, and sure enough, it was a ‘Burst; a very clean, all-original, late-1960 with loads of thin, tight curl. They wanted $2,000, cash – no trades. I left them a deposit and proceeded to go to my personal bank – Dad, what a guy! – and got the money.

“I was then known as ‘The Crazy Idiot Who Paid $2,000 For a Used Guitar!’

“My big brother, Bart, was afraid I’d been ripped off, so as soon as I could, I drove to Houston, interrupted his band practice – it didn’t take more than one glance at the brown case to call a break – and we both drooled over it. It was a classic late-’60, with a thin neck, first-style reflector-top knobs, and a bright cherry sunburst finish. I named it ‘Curly.’ I still have and love it!”

Richard Friedman
“[I bought] my first ‘Burst in ’69. A guy came into my store, Stuyvesant Music – later called We Buy Guitars – on 48th street in New York, and sold it to me for $275.

“I was ecstatic. I plugged it in to a 100-watt plexi and realized what gave Page, Beck, and Clapton that sound.”

Timm Kummer
“The first one I had was from an original owner from Trenton, New Jersey. I paid him $600. In ’75, that was more than a new one cost, but I wanted the same model as Jimmy Page. It wasn’t long before I sold it for $3,500.”

Drew Berlin
In San Fransisco in 1974, my band was playing a club called Country Roads. After the first set, I was approached by an older gentleman who said he had a guitar like mine, only in sunburst – I was playing my ’56 Les Paul Custom. I asked to see it. He brought it the next night and it turned out to be a ’58 with modest flame, and the color had faded. It had a lot of playing wear and the frets were very low, but he let me play it and I fell in love. I had to have that guitar!

“My bandmates thought I was crazy for paying $600 for it, but I kept if for many years, playing it at every gig. It was not only my first ‘Burst, but my best ‘Burst!”

Norm Harris
“In 1968, I saw an old one in a music store in Tampa, Florida. I played it, and I was amazed by how cool it was! So I bought it.”


The Crown Jewels
Which ‘Bursts are the most famous and/or influential?

Which 1958-’60 Les Paul is the one that caused it all?

Well, that’s a matter of opinion. Fortunately, guitarheads are opinionated, so when we asked dealers, collectors, and even some plain ol’ guitar music fans which ‘Bursts were significant in bringing the holy grail to prominence, here’s what they came up with.
1. Michael Bloomfield’s ’59
“Prior to Bloomfield, vintage acoustic guitars were collectible, but electrics were not,” said George Gruhn, a firm believer that Bloomfield is the primary reason solidbody electrics are so treasured today. “He, more than any other person, changed musicians’ views regarding electric guitar tone during the mid ’60s. The tens of thousands of musicians he influenced have changed the marketplace immeasurably.

“I fully acknowledge the tremendous significance of players such as Jimmy Page, Duane Allman, and Billy Gibbons in popularizing ‘Bursts. But these players all followed Bloomfield. It was Bloomfield, more than anyone else, who started the trend, and players who bought their first ‘Burst in ’68 or later may well have idolized stars other than Bloomfield, because by that time his career had virtually ended.”

2. Jimmy Page’s ’58
“As for making the ‘Burst what it is and putting it at the forefront, I gotta put Page at the front,” said Guitar Gallery’s Vic DaPra. “When I saw Zeppelin, Page used a couple of them onstage. Then I had to have two!”

3. The ’59s of Duane Allman, Billy Gibbons, and Peter Green
“These guys had been my heroes even before I really understood what a ‘Burst was,” said collector/dealer Tom Wittrock, Third Eye Music. “That they are great guitar players is widely accepted. But for me, the next step was realizing that a part of what I loved about them was the guitar and the tones it produced. Billy Gibbons ‘Pearly,’ pictured on ZZ Top’s First Album, was the benchmark for me. I could see the flame and hear the killer tones, and I associated those sounds with that ‘Burst.”

“‘Pearly Gates’ is a very important guitar, and it has a killer top,” added Timm Kummer. “And although it has some wear, it was put there by the Reverend, so it’s cool! And Duane Allman’s is one of the best examples of the dark color and fat flame that can make a guy forget the headstock has been on and off. That guitar has an awesome sound, look, and pedigree.”

4. Eric Clapton’s “Bluesbreaker” and the “Brock” ‘Burst
One fired shots heard loud and clear from across the Atlantic, the other is famous not for who played it, but for its sheer beauty.

“The ‘Brock ‘Burst’ found by Brian Brock – it’s on the cover of American Guitars, and it’s one of the better-looking tops, the color is excellent, and it’s famous,” said Kummer. “What more could you want?”

Guitar Center/Hollywood Vintage’s Drew Berlin agrees. “It’s also in The Beauty of the ‘Burst book [by Yasuhiko Iwanade], and is the most recognized ‘Burst of all time.”

5. Beck’s Blow By Blow guitar, Paul Kossoff’s ’59, and Ace Frehley’s

6. Honorable Mention
Joe Perry’s tobaccoburst ’59, as well as those played by John Sebastian, Joe Walsh, Charlie Daniels, Gary Rossington, Gary Richrath, and Slash.


The’ Burst from Minnesota Photo: First Light Productions, Minneapolis. Courtesy of Solidbodyguitar.com, Inc.

Bruce Barnes, a collector-broker and owner of Solidbody guitar.com, Inc. Moundsview, Minnesota, acquired this guitar, (he and his employees dubbed it the “Minnesota Burst”) through a network of friends and dealers in the farmlands of his home state.

“We were very excited when an original sunburst Les Paul was uncovered in this condition,” he said. “It was then brokered to a European buyer who wishes to remain anonymous. Many rumors of the prices paid for this piece have been circulated, but we have promised not to disclose the amount.”

Barnes’ affinity for the ‘Burst germinated in the late 1960s and early ’70s.

“When everyone was playing SG Standards with humbuckers, I went to an Allman Brothers show in St. Paul. I asked my friend, guitarist Tom Duncan, ‘Why is Duane’s Les Paul red, and yours is gold?’

“Since that day, I’ve had a fascination with the sunburst Les Paul.”

Barnes relates that it was a difficult decision to sell this magnificent example, #9 1103.

“But my oversprayed-refretted-Bigsby-removed-refinished-neck-no original-plastic-parts ’59 is part of my soul,” he said.

“I just hope this discovery gives all Les Paul collectors hope that there are still one or two more of these gems hiding in closets.”

It is indeed the stuff of dreams, from many standpoints.

“Based on the price paid for this piece – although the flame was extraordinary – and the limited number of original pieces, I believe the market for ‘Bursts can only escalate.”

This article originally appeared in VG‘s Sep. ’01 issue.

This entry was posted in Classic Instruments. Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.